Fight back! N3 speed cameras deemed illegal
CHECK THE DATES - KEEP YOUR MONEY
January 22, 2009
By Denis Droppa
Drivers caught speeding on camera at several roadworks sites on the Johannesburg ring road from September to November 2008 will be pleased to hear that the summonses are invalid because the camera traps were unauthorised.
However, they won't be pleased to hear that if they've already paid the fines they won't get a refund.
A reader contacted us to say he'd received a summons late in 2008 from a camera near the Marlboro off-ramp on the N3 freeway but when he went to the traffic department to pay the admission of guilt fine he was told the summons was invalid.
A helpful traffic officer told him to approach the court's public prosecutor, which he did and the summons was squashed without comment
Johannesburg Metro police spokesperson Superintendent Wayne Minnaar confirmed that speed cameras on the freeways circling the city - specifically those at roadworks sites - were used over that period without the necessary permission from Gauteng's director of public prosecutions.
But he said the authority has since been obtained and the traps had been operating legally since the beginning of December 2008.
He says the summonses issued wrongly should have been cancelled automatically. Motorists who received summonses over the affected period should go to court, speak to a traffic prosecutor and check that the camera trap was an authorised one.
If it wasn't, the case will be withdrawn.
There were reputedly some 60 000 "illegal" speeding summonses issued on the Johannesburg ring road from September to November 2008, though Minnaar could not confirm the number
Traffic authorities were similarly barred from using speed cameras on some of the busiest roads in the city in early 2008 because they missed application deadlines to operate the cameras.
However then, as now, motorists who'd already paid for summonses which they later suspected were invalid weren't refunded.
Minnaar said: "You can't get a refund because by paying an admission of guilt fine you've admitted that you were speeding."
The incident again underlines the importance of motorists checking the validity of summonses before paying the fines. A group calling itself the institute for the Scrutiny of Inequitable Traffic Enforcement has been set up to help drivers.
A spokesperson for the group said: "The speed camera system is inconsistently and arbitrarily set up by the Metro Police with the assistance of the judiciary.
"Our objective is to ensure that traffic laws are applied and enforced legally and fairly. Site membership is comprised of people from all walks of life, including ex-traffic policemen - even an ex-Provincial Traffic Chief.
"We have an exceptionally deep knowledge pool concerning traffic law. Our goal is to inform and educate drivers about their rights and to ensure that these rights are upheld when they're accused of traffic law infractions."
For more information call Dennis Jackson on (083) 497-6770.
By Denis Droppa
Drivers caught speeding on camera at several roadworks sites on the Johannesburg ring road from September to November 2008 will be pleased to hear that the summonses are invalid because the camera traps were unauthorised.
However, they won't be pleased to hear that if they've already paid the fines they won't get a refund.
A reader contacted us to say he'd received a summons late in 2008 from a camera near the Marlboro off-ramp on the N3 freeway but when he went to the traffic department to pay the admission of guilt fine he was told the summons was invalid.
A helpful traffic officer told him to approach the court's public prosecutor, which he did and the summons was squashed without comment
Speed cameras on the freeways circling the city were used without permission
.Johannesburg Metro police spokesperson Superintendent Wayne Minnaar confirmed that speed cameras on the freeways circling the city - specifically those at roadworks sites - were used over that period without the necessary permission from Gauteng's director of public prosecutions.
But he said the authority has since been obtained and the traps had been operating legally since the beginning of December 2008.
He says the summonses issued wrongly should have been cancelled automatically. Motorists who received summonses over the affected period should go to court, speak to a traffic prosecutor and check that the camera trap was an authorised one.
If it wasn't, the case will be withdrawn.
There were reputedly some 60 000 "illegal" speeding summonses issued on the Johannesburg ring road from September to November 2008, though Minnaar could not confirm the number
'By paying an admission of guilt fine you've admitted that you were speeding'
.
Traffic authorities were similarly barred from using speed cameras on some of the busiest roads in the city in early 2008 because they missed application deadlines to operate the cameras.
However then, as now, motorists who'd already paid for summonses which they later suspected were invalid weren't refunded.
Minnaar said: "You can't get a refund because by paying an admission of guilt fine you've admitted that you were speeding."
The incident again underlines the importance of motorists checking the validity of summonses before paying the fines. A group calling itself the institute for the Scrutiny of Inequitable Traffic Enforcement has been set up to help drivers.
A spokesperson for the group said: "The speed camera system is inconsistently and arbitrarily set up by the Metro Police with the assistance of the judiciary.
"Our objective is to ensure that traffic laws are applied and enforced legally and fairly. Site membership is comprised of people from all walks of life, including ex-traffic policemen - even an ex-Provincial Traffic Chief.
"We have an exceptionally deep knowledge pool concerning traffic law. Our goal is to inform and educate drivers about their rights and to ensure that these rights are upheld when they're accused of traffic law infractions."
For more information call Dennis Jackson on (083) 497-6770.
Free NEWSLETTER
Right-click on ad for new window.
HOME
- FIRST DRIVES: Hyundai's new 'Tucson' and sexy Sonata
- Killer crash bags in fresh recall scandal
- Drivers and cars ill-equipped for when panic strikes
- Patrick ready for Nascar debut after baptism of fire
- Israel on track to switch-on battery-car grid
- Drop-top driving without the draught in Megane CC
- WE DRIVE: Rolls Royce Ghost
- Not again! Bungled demerit system back on hold
- Adkins' diet drinker had slim chance of acquittal
- 'So sorry!' Toyota president tells world
LATEST LAUNCHES
- Impreza RS - the WRX's baby brother
- Range-topping Subarus tackle premium market
- Big Volvos join the 'green scheme'
- VW's Scirocco blows harder with 155kW engine
- World premiere for all-new Kia Sportage at Geneva
- True grit: Peugeot proves its 3008 in the Kalahari
- Edgy Mazda BT-50 ready for SA's toughest playgrounds
- Porsche Panamera - belting performance, bizarre looks
- SECOND LOOK: BMW's new 5 Series
- New face for Lexus GS - including the hybrid
ROAD TESTS
- WE DRIVE: Lexus' answer to M3 and Stuttgart stormer
- Golf 1.6 TDI - great car, pity about the engine
- WE DRIVE: BMW's brilliant 5 Series Gran Turismo
- JAMES MARTIN: Gadget-packed Mercedes S-Class
- BMW 535i GT - 'good times' car faces hump of a slump
- WE DRIVE: Bentley's fastest production car yet
- JAMES MARTIN: Lamborghini Gallardo LP 560-4 Spyder
- Mud or snow - Toyota's Prado keeps going right
- Touch of Botox for Nissan's new baby bakkie
- There's a fair bit of kit in Alfa's spirited Mito
F1 GRAND PRIX
- Button agrees terms with McLaren - report
- Glock signs for new GP team
- No bonus for Button from Mercedes takeover
- Senna keen to make his own name in F1
- World champion team Brawn bought out
- Mercedes exit good for McLaren, says Dennis
- Button tours McLaren factory
- Alonso already dreaming of world title with Ferrari
- New Lotus F1 team signs first driver
- US F1 on track for 2010 - IAF senate head(V)
MOTORSPORT
- Battery power lights up US drag strips(V)
- Patrick ready for Nascar debut after baptism of fire
- Brit cat back on track for 2010 Le Mans 24 Hours
- 'Bigger engines could keep me in MotoGP' - Rossi
- Last-lap stunner in first Phakisa Free State 500
- Phakisa 500 - SA drivers star in first practice session
- SA riders head for frozen Hell's Gate
- Oval-track aces set to clash at Killarney
- Six SA drivers named to race Free State 500
- Polished finish gives Ford Monte Carlo victory(V)



